Posted on

Business Essays – Michelin Star System

Michelin Star System

Michelin Star System

Chapter 2 Literature Review

The system of evaluation administrations with a peculiar concern sector harmonizing to the value and quality that these administrations provide to the terminal user, by methods such as those used by the Michelin Guide Star System is nil new. However, it is of import for the proprietors of these administrations to understand the relevancy of such systems. For illustration, are they most relevant to the consumer in footings of run intoing their demands and outlooks and therefore act uponing behavior or to the administration in footings of bettering its standing within the concern sector and beef uping trade name consciousness? Get downing with the consumer, this critical literature reappraisal is intended to supply an apprehension of the current theories and observations associating to these peculiar issues.

2.1 Consumer demands and satisfaction

Abraham Maslow ‘s ( 1998 ) hierarchy of demands theory is recognised by most faculty members as holding created the foundation for all subsequent research into understanding the consumer, supplying a model that allows administrations providing a merchandise of service to better understanding how they need to show these in order to fulfill the consumer demand, therefore accomplishing their aim of increasing market portion. The research carried out by Szmigin ( 2003 ) and Porter ( 2004 ) besides confirms that the success of a concerns scheme is besides dependent upon the extent to which that scheme is designed to run into and hence address the sensed satisfaction degrees of the consumer.

Get aid with your essay from our adept essay authors…

Figure 1 Maslow ‘s hierarchy of demands

Esteem demands

accomplishment, position, duty, repute


personal growing and fulfillment

Belongingness and Love demands

household, fondness, relationships, work group, etc.

Safety demands

protection, security, order, jurisprudence, bounds, stableness, etc.

Biological and Physiological demands

basic life needs – air, nutrient, drink, shelter, heat, sex, slumber, etc.

In associating the Maslow theory straight to the satisfaction of demands of the consumer with respects to their eating house experience, it can be seen from the above diagram ( figure 1 ) , that this is dependent upon the degree at which the consumer is within the hierarchy. For illustration, it is likely that those at the three basic degrees of demand will be less driven by optimum quality than monetary value and gait to carry through that demand ( Noone et al 2007 and Namkung and SonCheong 2007 ) . The satisfaction of these degrees of demand is likely to be more of import for the tourer sector of the cordial reception industry, where the repast is expected to organize merely a portion of their overall holiday experience ( Atila and Fisun 2003 ) .

However, where regard and self-actualisation becomes more of import is when the consumer wants to do a statement that separates him or her from the crowd. For illustration, if a sales representative wishes to do an feeling with a prospective client, they are likely to desire to dine in a eating house that delivers a higher degree of quality. In other words they will be looking for a perfect experience that will fulfill those they are seeking to affect ( Gupta et al. August 2007 and Chemlinski, R. , 2006 ) .

2.2 Consumer behavior

The behavioral forms of consumer, as with all human reactions, are dependent upon reactions that can ensue from a psychological, emotional or physical influence. One of the most influential factors that influence consumer behavior is that of memory. Everything we do is affected by memory, and this will drive our witting and sub-conscious reaction to a peculiar event and the ultimate picks that we make. However, the memories formed are besides affected by the mode in which preexistent experiences construe them ( Zaltman 2003, p.186 ) . For illustration, if we have had a bad experience at a peculiar eating house in the yesteryear, it is likely that this will discourage us from reiterating the experience, irrespective of how that peculiar eating house may seek to re-package the experience.

One of the troubles that the eating house proprietor has with presenting satisfaction of demands to the consumer of their merchandise consequences from the fact that memory determiners of consumer pick are driven by both witting and unconscious idea procedures and therefore can be about impossiblefor an foreigner to see and mensurate, allow entirely change( Zaltman 2003, p.15 ) . This is surely true in relation to actions ensuing from subconscious memory as, in this instance, as Bagozzi et Al ( 2002, p.132 ) observe, even the individual doing the pick could be incognizant of why they have reacted in the manner they did. The memory procedures will act upon the mode in which the consumer makes a opinion about the benefits of the eating house merchandise and service being offered. Based upon old memories it will subconsciously inform the consumer whether the expected experience is likely to be negative or ( Zaltman et al 2002, p.68 ) . Furthermore, the consumer will besides so utilize that memory to judge whether the experience will take to a satisfaction of their current degree of demand ( Maslow 1998 ) .

2.3 Branding and the consumer

Brand image is another of import factor that will act upon the consumer ‘s pick of purchase. It is an about automatic reaction of the consumer to do an association between the trade name and what it denotes. For illustration, in footings of eating houses and cordial reception, the trade name McDonald ‘s automatically conjures up an image of fast, inexpensive nutrient or the Burger type assortment. Irrespective of the accommodations that the Burger concatenation attempts to do to their merchandises, such is the deepness of that association within the head of the consumer that it will be about impossible to alter Haig ( 2004, p.78 and 85 ) . Once a trade name has been created hence, altering the consumer ‘s perceptual experience of it is highly hard.

One of the jobs that the Michelin Star System has in regard of trade name image is that it has, consciously or unconsciously within the mentality of the consumer, created an image of quality, but with that quality being achieved at a monetary value. In the heads of certain sections of the consumer populace this puts their recommendations beyond the bounds of affordability, irrespective of whether it will fulfill their demands ( Surlemont et al 2005 ) . However, Porter ( 2004 ) would reason that the distinction in footings of the quality of the merchandise and the monetary value premium could hold certain competitory advantages. For illustration, it would appeal to those who wish to put themselves apart from the multitudes or, as indicated earlier, are seeking to make an feeling for their ain intents. Furthermore, as the research on consumer behavior conducted by Zaltman ( 2003, p.227 ) suggests, this distinction may besides be able to bring forth satisfaction in footings of another influential factor that exists within the consumer decision-making procedure, this being peer influence. It is good recorded that our perceptual experience of what others think has a important influence upon the manner we make determinations. For illustration, we will frequently do determinations merely in an attempt to be connected to a peculiar group or section of people. As mentioned earlier, within the eating house experience this may attest itself in the demand to affect others. However, in the cordial reception sector it can be said to be every bit true that people will dine at a certain eating house merely as a agency of doing a statement, which indicates to others that one is within a different consumer group. In this instance, the consumer will be fulfilling the Maslow ( 1998 ) degrees of demand that relates to self-esteem and realization.

2.4 Restaurant acknowledgment

Literature does nevertheless demo that the Michelin evaluation system and the acknowledgment it brings does do a difference within some countries of the sector ( Guide 2008 ) . From listening to the picture of the remarks of Gary Rhodes and Anthony Demetre ( Video Links 2008 ) , it is evident that to the owners of the eating houses concerned both consider that it improves the quality of their several trade names, which in bend will heighten the concern thrust for success. This position is reinforced by the reaction of those who lose or fail to derive stars, which shows obvious letdown ( Latest intelligence 2008 ) .

2.5 Drumhead

In the sentiment of the writer, the literature evaluated for this reappraisal shows why there is such a diverseness of sentiment sing the relevancy of the Michelin Star System within the current eating house sector of the leisure and cordial reception sector. There are those whose theories argue that, except for the higher degrees of fulfilling the consumer demands ( Maslow 1998 ) , which relate to self-esteem and realization, it has small impact upon the mean consumer. Similarly, many consumers perceive that its influence is more related to the pricing scheme and eating house environment than in presenting service satisfaction to the consumer ( Snyder and Cotter 1998 ) . However, employees and proprietors within the industry would reason that the Michelin Star has a good impact in that it increases the strength of the trade name ( Balasz K 2002 ) and that it denotes an confidence of quality that the consumer can trust upon.

Chapter 3 Research Methodology

As McGivern ( 2006, p.4 ) observes within her survey on the topic, researchis about a systematic probes to happen things out, which means that the research worker has to inventa system of methods and regulations to ease the aggregation and analysis of informations( Hart 2006, p.28 ) . Thus it follows that the peculiar method adopted for any research undertaking has important importance in relation to the intended purposes and aims of the survey being conducted.

Basically, informations used in a research surveies can be collected through one of two methods. These are the primary resource, which frequently entails the direct aggregation of informations through the usage of studies, interviews and questionnaires, or the secondary resource, which relies upon the usage preexistent informations ( Clark 2002 ) . The determination that every research worker faces is which of these methods, of combination thereof, is most appropriate to the capable affair of their research undertaking.

Bearing these factors in head, the purpose of this chapter is to supply the reader with an lineation of the methodological analysis chosen by the writer for this survey into the Michelin Star System.

3.1 Choice of research design

The eating house sector of the leisure and touristry industry in which the Michelin Star System operates is diverse, both in footings of the Numberss of take parting market participants, the concern theoretical accounts used and the consumer audience to which they appeal. With the UK Michelin usher covering a sum of over 4,500 hotels and eating houses ( Hickman 2008 ) it is besides a ample sector for any research to cover. Furthermore, due to the importance of the eating house sector in relation to the leisure and touristry industries, together with its influence upon the consumer, there is a proliferation of preexistent academic and practical informations available in relation to this sector, which is being increased on a regular footing. These include empirical surveies in targeted leisure and cordial reception diaries, observations from external stakeholders such as magazines and newspapers and legion on a regular basis conducted questionnaires and studies.

The considerations to be given to the pick of the research design was hence to measure whether this degree of secondary informations would supply a sufficiency of information to add value to the research being conducted or if nearing the research utilizing a primary information attack would turn out to be of more relevancy to the purposes and aims that form the footing of this paper.

In the concluding analysis the writer decided to plan the research around the secondary informations attack. In making this determination, there were several grounds for the discarding of the primary option. The first of these took into history the restrictions that would attach to primary informations aggregation. Of necessity, the completion of this research is restrained by a unequivocal clip set for its completion. Furthermore, in position of the size of the sector, it was considered that to build and carry on a sufficiently robust primary informations pick, through the usage of questionnaires and interviews would be cost prohibitory. For illustration, there would necessitate to be a sufficiently big sample of such informations aggregation achieved through eating house employees, consumers and other stakeholders to make a representative sample, which in the writer ‘s sentiment could non be achieved within the prevalent restrictions.

It is recognised that secondary informations has two possible disadvantages. First, with this method, the research worker is reliant upon the cogency of informations being collected from an external beginning over which they have no control ; hence there is no direct cognition of the responses and theories available. Second, there is besides the issue of the cogency of the informations to be considered. However, its chief advantage is the deepness and comprehensiveness of the sum of informations available.

It taking a design based upon secondary informations it is recognised that there are two possible disadvantages. First, with this method the research worker is reliant upon the cogency of informations being collected from an external beginning over which they have no control ; hence there is no direct cognition of the responses and theories available. Second, there is besides the issue of the cogency of the informations to be considered.

However, in add-on to the restrictions attached to the aggregation of primary informations, there were besides positive grounds for taking the usage of secondary informations as the foundation for the design of this research paper. The first of these relates straight to the fact that, from an initial explorative scrutiny of the informations field, it is evident that much of the secondary information is of a higher quality and has a more extended coverage than could be achieve from a primary method ( Punch 1998 ) . Second, as the purpose of this thesis concentrates upon the current value and relevancy of the Michelin Star System, it is necessary to analyze the differing positions and theories of faculty members and research workers in regard of those who are likely to be affected by the system, including the eating house operators and their clients. In this regard the theory associating to concern stigmatization, quality and competitory advantage, such as those promoted by Arnold ( 1992 ) and Porter ( 2004 ) demand to be considered. From the client facet, understanding the demands, outlooks and behavioral forms need to be included. For this country was considered that the academic surveies and theories promoted by writers such as Abraham Maslow ( 1998 ) and Szmigin ( 2003 ) are besides relevant. It is by and large accepted that these writers have a high degree of expertnesss and hence, as Dingwell ( 1997 ) and Steward and Kasmins ( 2003 ) suggest, their plants will adds a higher degree of quality to the research being conducted for this survey.

In making the pick of utilizing secondary informations for the design of this peculiar research, the writer took the same position as other research workers, such as Steward and Kamins ( 1993 ) , McGivern ( 2006 ) and Hart ( 2006 ) . These writers suggest that the type of methodological analysis used is non excessively of import supplying the informations and information collected is dependable, trusty and resolves the inquiries being posed within the research aims and aims. The writer is confident that the picks for secondary informations made fulfil these standards.

3.2 Construction of the chosen method

It is of import that the right attack is used in covering with the measure of informations collected and its subsequent analysis and rating. This is peculiarly the instance in footings of extinguishing any prejudice that exists within the head of the writer. In this peculiar instance it is the considered position of the writer that, potentially, the research may reason that the Michelin star system is merely of relevancy to the internal stakeholders of the eating house sectors, viz. the chefs and proprietors, and is paid little regard to from the consumers point of view.

Therefore, in choosing a scope of between 30 and 40 mentions from a scope of databases, which includes books, professional diaries, studies and studies, web sites and other on-line resources, these issues have been borne in head. For illustration, in order to equilibrate the possible prejudice, resources have been chosen that support the current relevancy of the Michelin Star System current relevancy every bit good as those beginnings that take the opposite point of view. Similarly, for the same ground it was felt the relationship between consumer demands, behavior and stigmatization besides needed to be addressed, as this will supply a position of the influence that a Michelin Star trade name has upon the terminal user of the eating house installations.

3.3 Sample

The sample of literature used within this research has been chosen from a figure of relevant beginnings. In the chief the concentration has been upon choosing resources from the most current available beginnings, being by and large that produced within the last two to three decennaries, as this was considered to be the most appropriate for the issues being discussed. Similarly, the sampling was concentrated chiefly upon the UK. The lone exclusion to this was in instances such as Maslow ‘s hierarchy of demands, which is considered to incorporate the founding rules of consumer behavioral determiners.

With the exclusion of the theoretical literature, where the attack of writer pick was made for the grounds discussed in subdivision 4.1 above, the trying method used was based upon the maximal fluctuation attack ( Hart 1998 and 2006 ) as this was felt to supply a steadfast foundation from which to turn to the aims of the survey.

3.4 Procedure

The process used for the aggregation of the secondary information was through the normal database channels of diaries, books accessed from libraries and forte bookstores and on-line resources. However, these hunts were farther defined to guarantee that there was a direct relevancy to the touristry and leisure industry, with peculiar concentration upon cordial reception.

3.5 Data analysis

Having collected the information utilizing the antecedently defined methods and choice picks, it so needed to be analysed and evaluated. A double attack was used for this intent. The first phase involved correlating the information into differing point of views, for illustration those who considered the Michelin star relevant and those that did non. The 2nd phase required measuring the relevancy that the assorted theories studied had in a practical application.

Chapter 4 Findingss

As has been discovered within the literature reappraisal, there are conflicting sentiments as to whether the Michelin Star system of quality measuring is of value within the eating house industry. Using available secondary informations within this chapter is in tended to show an analysis of the findings of the current sentiment and research on this issue, which will so be discussed in deepness.

4.1 The Michelin Star wages system

The Michelin Guide, which derives its name from the Tyre company from which it originated, was foremost introduced in France in 1900 ( Johnson et al 2005 ) . Its original purpose was to help drivers with proficient and travel advice. From there it developed into a tourer usher until finally, in the 1930 ‘s, it became the gastronomic usher that it is renowned as today. By 2005 the Red Guide, as it had become known, was selling over one million transcripts across eight states ( Johnson et al 2005 ) .

Restaurants and other eating constitutions can non be included within the usher until their location has been visited and the repasts judged by a dedicated squad of inspectors. In order to avoid accusals of prejudice and to guarantee independency, these inspectors are employed by Michelin and are required to pay for their repasts and any adjustment that may be required. In fact, they besides do non inform the constitution of the ground for their visit until after their review has taken topographic point. In this regard, Michelin suggest, and other research has confirmed ( Balasz 2001 ) , the consequences of the reviews show a greater degree of independency than that of some other ushers, which give progress notice of the review and do non anticipate to hold to settle the repast measure.

Harmonizing to the Michelin Guides Direct, Mr Naret, the Michelin inspectors are besides non swayed by the name of the chef or the constitution. This was made evident in a recent interview where he said, “Inspectors are n’t looking at the name. They do n’t care whether the chef is on telecasting or how many of his cookery books you might hold on your shelf. They enter the eating house and look entirely at what is on the home base: the quality of ingredients, how they are cooked, how good the spirits are kept, presentation, personality and consistence“ ( Foster 2007 ) , although every bit will be discussed subsequently, there is some dissension over this claim.

The Inspectors, of which there are presently around 70 runing throughout Europe, are individuals who have had at least five old ages experience within the hotel and catering industry, peculiarly in regard of the culinary art component. Prior to being allowed to get down their review responsibilities, these individuals besides have to undergo a vigorous six months developing programme to guarantee that they meet with and keep the needed Michelin criterions ( Johnson et al 2005 ) . Michelin states that on mean one inspector will execute the undermentioned undertakings during the class of a twelvemonth: –

Inspect 240 repasts per annum

Undertake 130 nightlong corsets

Submit 1000 studies

It has to be stated that this is an exceptionally heavy work load for one individual. It is partly because of this degree of activity that some adept perceivers, and so restauranters ‘ themselves, hold called into inquiry the quality, rightness and cogency of the review squads work and decisions. This component of concern is discussed in ulterior subdivisions within this chapter.

The usher includes a broad scope eating constitutions, most of which are included merely for information intents, with these numbering about 50,000 in figure, a degree that is invariably increasing. However, amongst this figure around five per centum are picked out for particular reference, these being rated based upon the awarding of the desired Michelin Star to them. There are up to three stars available, the awarding of which depends upon the consistence of quality and, as Johnson et Al ( 2005 ) explain, To some extent tradition. Michelin denote the definition of their stars as follows: –

One Star

A really good eating house in its ain class

Two Stars

Excellent cookery, worth a roundabout way

Three Stars

Exceeding culinary art worth a particular journey. One ever eats highly good here, sometimes wonderfully.

In 2005 a farther virtue acknowledgment was introduced, which was called the Bib Gourmand. This is awarded to an constitution that had non rather managed to make the degree of quality required to accomplish one star position, but which was considered by the inspector to be able to accomplish that place within the close hereafter.

Although there is limited information available as to the standards which is used for the finding of the star degree being awarded, in the chief this relies upon the criterion exhibited within the undermentioned five countries: –

Meal ingredient quality

Culinary accomplishments exhibited in readying and the combination of spirits

Degree of creativeness that has been displayed

How consistent the repast criterions at the constitution are

Monetary value of the merchandise

4.2 General academic perceptual experience of the Michelin Brand and competition

Academicians such as Johnson et Al ( 2005 ) , Yuksel and Yuksel ( 2003 ) and Balasz ( 2001 ) have mixed positions about the quality and relevancy of the Michelin Star system. Yuksel and Yuksel ( 2003 ) in their research into the systems entry into the Nipponese culinary market, suggest that, in that state at least, the usher fails to take into history the people factor. In other, it is being suggested that by utilizing paid professionals, the Michelin administrations does non pay sufficient attending to the qualities of dependability and satisfaction that lead to reiterate use of the constitution by the consumers. This country is considered by many faculty members that survey consumer behavior to be of equal importance to the criterion of the menu being offered ( Bagozzi et al 2002 ) and should hence be incorporated into the Michelin processs.

The 2nd component of concern expressed related to the force per unit area that the Michelin Star System placed upon the constitution chefs and proprietors. Although, as Johnson et Al ‘s ( 2005 ) research concluded, the ownership of a Michelin stardoes non vouchprofitableness, its loss was discovered to hold serious deductions for the concern, with some sing gross decreases of up to 50 % when this state of affairs occurred.

Issues of a practical nature in relation to the Michelin Start system have besides been raised by many perceivers. There is a general position that the contemplation of alterations within eating constitutions is non dealt with expeditiously by the Michelin inspectors, with the awarding or remotion of stars neglecting to maintain up with these alterations in many instances. There is small uncertainty that the inordinate work load of the Michelin inspectors outlined in subdivision 4.1 is a conducive factor in the happening of these holds.

Furthermore, it is felt by many that, outside of the Star system arising market, France ; the evaluation system lacks the same degree of dependability. This will be evidenced by the response from the Nipponese eating house industry presented in the undermentioned subdivision.

Surlemont and Johnson ‘s ( 2005, p.589 ) research besides indicated that, in their sentiment, there were some defects within the Michelin star system. In the first of these it was noted that there were eating houses included within the varied stars that did non deserve their places, which adds to the perceptual experience that there might be a job with the quality and dependability of the system and its operating processs. Second, the deficiency of a structured measuring procedure being implemented by Michelin, its awarding of stars being entirely at the discretion of inspector studies, did intend that the chefs had no definable mark to take for. Alternatively they merely had todevelop their ain manner and be patient,and hope that it would be noticed and appreciated by the Michelin inspectors at some phase.

Another country that has been questioned with respect to the Michelin Star system is its prevalence for print ushers. Although the company has late introduced online installations for consumers to react to the content of the ushers, the chief method of information distribution is through the published ushers, which at monetary values get downing at around 9.99 ( $ 20.00 ) is seen by some consumers to be rather expensive, particularly as entree to restaurant reappraisals and remarks is freely available through the Internet. Bagozzi et Al ( 2002 ) , indicate that consumers pay a considerable sum of attending to peer force per unit area and remarks, and the Internet provides them with entree to this type of response. Others such as Zaltman ( 1998 ) besides suggest that the trust upon equals can be a strong determinate for purchase, therefore if consumers recommend eating house trade names in many instances this will bring forth a more positive consequence upon others than the professional attack of recommendations provided by Michelin. The recent bead in guide gross revenues in Europe shows that this state of affairs is impacting the strength of the Michelin trade name, at least in this geographical country, and is seen as portion of the ground for the guides enlargement into the US and Asia.

In add-on, there are rivals to Michelin Guides. There are two that are peculiarly worthy of note. The first, which has built a important market portion in the UK, is the AA Rosette system, which is awarded to hotels and eating houses for their culinary criterions. In this instance there is a five star system in operation, with the lowest being awarded to eating houses of note in their peculiar location to the highest being awarded to constitutions that are considered to be universe category. There are consumers and perceivers who believe that the AA Rosette system is a more dependable index of quality than Michelin.

The other usher that is having good reappraisals, and like the Michelin usher originates from France, is the Zagat usher. What has brought this usher to the attending of culinary perceivers is the fact that its evaluation system is based upon an collection of the sentiments of unpaid single consumers their experiences of the eating house constitution ( Gobe 2002, p.139 ) . Michelin would reason that this is non a professional attack to the finding of quality, criterions and culinary accomplishments. However, the fact that the Zagat usher is increasing in popularity indicates that it is holding an impact upon consumer pick and behavior.

4.3 Industry reaction to the Michelin Brand

Within the culinary industry itself there is considerable argument about the value of the Michelin star system, with the protagonists and oppositions of this award being every bit vocal in showing their positions on the topic.

For illustration, in footings of state prejudice, a study of 791 Michelin-ranked eating houses conducted by Johnson et Al ( 2005 ) conducted throughout eight states indicated that France was favoured in the awarding of stars, with it beingplace to 62 per centum of the one-star eating houses, 67 per centum of the two-star eating houses, and 25 of the 32 three-star operations.

Furthermore, its fiscal importance to fiscal success is besides argued. For illustration, whilst Belasz ( 2002 ) suggests that keeping a Michelin star can supply an constitution can be a cardinal determiner for its fiscal success, Johnson et Al ( 2005 ) disputes this claim, happening in their research that in most instances there was no indicant of this being the instance, at least in footings of profitableness. However, Johnson et Al did profess that the Michelin star made a difference to gross in most instances, although this does non intend that the eating house became more profitable as a consequence.

The impact that the Michelin stars have had upon chefs and their reactions to the system has besides been diverse. As Balasz ( 2001 and 2002 ) references in her research into behavior and leading within the cordial reception industry, chefsbelong to the rare species of persons who are able to take on the duel function of bourgeois and Godhead at the same clip.Mentioning besides to their dedication to the trade of culinary creative activity, Balasz besides mentions that chef ‘s attack this with an aboutsacred compulsionand in this regard they aspire merely to be the best. Therefore, it is non surprising that the Michelin star system has a important affect upon these people.

There are many chefs and culinary constitutions that crave being awarded the stars and do small secret of this desire. For case, in add-on to the response from Television chefs Rhodes and Demetre ( Video links 2008 ) , one of their equals Gordon Ramsey, whose assorted constitutions are said to presently keep the most figure of stars ( 12 ) , was besides delighted with the recent add-ons to this elect nine, which occurred with the acknowledgment of his eating house based in Manhattan, New York. In the Editorial ( 2007 ) , Ramsey expounded the position that it showed the quality and client value that the staff at the eating house delivered to the client. However, other US nutrient critics and perceivers did non portion Michelin ‘s sentiment, branding the nutrient as ‘overcooked ‘ , ‘rubbery ‘ , ‘leathery ‘ and ‘a distinguishable letdown.However, other American chefs are back uping of the Michelin evaluation system. Eric Ripert and Mario Batali, both of whom have been starred by Michelin have indicated that it is of import to their concerns ( Petkanas 2006 ) . Ripert suggested that those who were kicking about the force per unit area Michelin stardom placed upon the chef were misguided and, every bit far as he was concerned, it had a positive consequence upon the profitableness of his eating house. Similarly, Batali, who runs a eating house in New York, indicated that inclusion was good as in his sentiment many Americans relied upon it, peculiarly when going abroad, although he felt that the criterions should concentrate more uponthe cooking alternatively of the tabular array scene( Petkanas 2006 ) .

Other support for the system has come from unexpected topographic points, such as Holland. In a study conducted with restauranters in the Netherlands ( Gehrels et al 2006, p.51 ) it was found that 53.84 % considered that being included within the Michelin Guide was the most of import component of their promotional activities. Furthermore, 30.77 % were of the sentiment that the usher was influential as a tool for word of oral cavity publicity by consumers, in other words the consumer would be happy to advance eating houses that had been mentioned in the usher to others.

However, there has besides been a batch of unfavorable judgment from renowned chefs aimed at the Michelin Star system. Some of these unfavorable judgments have emanated from eating houses that have non been included within the star system. For illustration the proprietor of a Paris bistro Le Comptoir, who has been on the Michelin waiting list, criticises the publication, reasoning that despite hisbistro specializing in great regional cookery and yet once more it barely rates a spark on Michelin ‘s graduated table. He goes on to inquirewho is the victor? One thing ‘s for certain: it ‘s non Michelin ‘s readers( Elliott 2008 ) .

If such unfavorable judgment were to be seem as merely being voiced by those who have non been honoured with one or more of the Michelin it could be argued, as some have done ( Elliott 2008 ) , that this could be a simple instance of showing letdown. However, over the past few old ages at that place has been an increasing sum of unfavorable judgment being levelled at the Michelin system from outstanding chefs who have been systematically accomplishing high degrees of star acknowledgment.

One of the most noticeable desertions from the Michelin Star evaluations is Alain Senderens, who use to run the Lucas Carton eating house in Paris ( Petkanas 2006 ) . Senderens, who held the three star Michelin honor for about three decennaries has late renounced his inclusion in this evaluation system and, harmonizing to Petkanas ( 2006 ) he is one of many Gallic chefs who are taking similar action, preferring to trust upon their ain criterion of quality and criterions to increase their concern and its profitableness degrees. Senderens ailment against the Michelin system is that it honorpuffed-up service, boilerplate “ luxury, ” and dishes with sticker-shock ingredients like lobster and caviar,instead than concentrating upon what was truly wanted by the consumer. Another of Sendersens unfavorable judgment relates to the cost of accomplishing star position, which can be seen from his remark that “Person has to pay for all that: the client. To win three stars you must run a really formal operation and do a monumental economic investing. If the China is n’t Dior, Michelin is n’t interested.In his position,You should be able to utilize fictile tablecloths and acquire three stars. You should acquire them for what ‘s on the home base.

This degree of unfavorable judgment is non reserved for the Gallic either. In London, one of the metropolis ‘s most extremely regarded chefs, Landanis, has voiced similar concerns and reserves. Whilst holding with the Gallic Chef positions that the type of nutrients and the costs of making the required atmosphere to present the criterion required by Michelin are out of touch with world, Landanis goes farther. He has two other issues with the Michelin system. In the first topographic point, bearing in head the competitory nature of chefs and others in the eating house concern, he believes that, in fuelling that fight it is driving up the monetary value of eating out to the hurt of the consumer, these being the really people who are supposed to profit from the evaluations. In other words he is proposing that the star system is more seen as an look of inter-chef competition that carry throughing its original purposes. His other issues with it is that, in his sentiment, Landis believes that the relevancy of the Michelin star system is non as strongly felt in London as it is in France.

As noted earlier, this latter point of view expressed by Landanis has besides been echoed in Japan, where the Michelin Star system has late been introduced ( Frackler 2008 ) . Many of import Nipponese chefs, including Toshiya Kadowaki, have turned down the chance to be ranked within the Michelin system, despite the fact that some of his most noteworthy dishes are French-inspired.

Part of the expostulations being raised by Nipponese chefs is aimed at the deficiency of local cognition of Nipponese civilization and traditions that Michelin inspectors have, and for this ground they find the evaluation system unpalatable. In Franker ‘s ( 2008 ) study, Kadowaki summed this feeling up when he commented that.Nipponese nutrient was created here, and merely Nipponese know it. How can a clump of aliens show up and state us what is good or bad?

These inauspicious chef positions about the relevancy of Michelin star evaluation have been reported liberally throughout the media and these publications are besides showing concern about the issue. For illustration, William Sitwell, which is the editor of the in-store Waitrose Food Illustrated ( Elliott 2008 ) commented that chefs had told him that theusher was defending nutrient that people no longer wished to eat. It seems to me that excessively many chefs are break one’s backing in the kitchen to delight Michelin and acquire stars, when people are looking for less poncey and more normal nutrient.His position on this was that, because of the spread of these concerns, there was serious concern within the industry that the Michelin system had ceased to go relevant.

Finally, other industry concerns have been aiming the transparence and prejudice of the Michelin system. In peculiar this concern Centre ‘s on what is seen to be an autochthonal prejudice towards the Gallic and Gallic culinary art. In giving substance to this sentiment, it has been noted by perceivers that the development of Michelin stars in New York has exhibited prejudices. New York has four constitutions that have earned Michelin ‘s three star position. However, out of this figure three are being run by Gallic chefs, these beingAlain Ducasse at Alain Ducasse, Jean-Georges Vongerichten at Jean Georges, and Eric Ripert at Le Bernardin.The suggestion is that this is non a happenstance, but a mark of the fact that the Michelin inspectors use Gallic culinary art and cookery expertness as an unjust measuring of criterions against which it compares constitutions that are either outside of France or whose chefs do non exhibit similar accomplishments in footings of the types of repasts that they present.

It has to be noted that recent inauspicious incidences affecting the Michelin usher have merely served to increase the degrees of concerns being expressed. For illustration, in 2005 a eating house in Ostend, Belgium, was given the evaluation of Bib Gourmand despite the fact that it had non even opened for concern ( BBC News 2005 ) . In fact it was several hebdomads after the usher had been published that the said eating house foremost opened its doors to the populace. This brought into inquiry the cogency of the reviews being performed and the criterion of those being employed by Michelin. This state of affairs was farther inflamed by a book written by a helping inspector, who suggested that there was bias towards certain chefs, which meant that they were about guaranteed of their star evaluations and, moreover, that there were non adequate inspectors to present the expected degree of service ( BBC News 2005 ) .

4.4 Consumer reaction to the Michelin Brand

It is a by and large held belief that, in the eyes of the consumer, the eating house and its owners/chef ‘s service two chief intents. These are to fulfill the consumer ‘s demand for an experience that delivers to their demands in footings of quality and criterion of the culinary merchandise and the clip spent in the eating house environment. In other words, satisfaction of the consumer demands is paramount ( Bagozzi et al 2002 ) . From a competitory point of view, this means that the restauranter, to better market portion and therefore the profitableness of his or her concern, has to make a concern that exhibits sufficient distinction to promote consumer ‘s to take their constitutions in penchant to another ( Muller 1999, p.401 ) .

Furthermore, as the Nipponese research conducted by Yuksel and Yuksel ( 2003, p.52 ) affirms, non all consumer sections have the same degrees of buying determiners. For illustrations, the degrees of quality and satisfaction will non be equal across the whole of the consumer cleavages ( Zaltman 2003 ) , with non merely different groups holding different outlooks but besides the fact that these outlooks differ depending upon the experience being required. For illustration, those on holiday may be looking at a eating house experience in a really different manner to the concern individual who is seeking to affect his clients, or the romantic who is looking to observe a particular juncture.

The trouble that many consumers perceive to be the instance with the Michelin star evaluation system is that much of it is concentrated upon the higher choice terminal of the market, peculiarly in the instance if the higher star evaluations. Furthermore, because all of the chefs within this sector are seen to be viing for criterions and quality that are measured in a mode that tends to bring forth a similar experience, there is besides consumer concern that the component of pick is more limited than the all of the consumer sections would want. This is confirmed in the Nipponese research mentioned earlier where Yuksel and Yuksel ( 2003, p.52 ) identified that there were five typical consumer sections and that each one of these expect different degrees of quality and service.

Furthermore, as mentioned earlier, there is increasing grounds that the consumer is traveling off from reacting entirely to information provided from what they consider professional beginnings, which would include the Michelin usher and star system. As Poiesz ( 2004, p.317 ) explains in his research into consumer behavior, the modern consumer will besidesrely upon information made available from other beginnings.With increased degrees of leisure and societal activities, together with the enlargement of Internet usage, many of these other beginnings originate from the remarks and Hagiographas of other consumers. As Zaltman ( 2003 ) explains, the grade of trust and assurance that consumers have in each other is, in many instances, stronger than the bond of trust that can be developed between a commercial or professional administration and the consumer. Therefore, from this consideration, many would reason that the Michelin usher is losing its relevance and importance for the consumer because of the deficiency of inclusion of single client experiences within the evaluation measurings. In other words, the perceptual experience of the consumer might be that the criterions of the Michelin inspectors is designed more towards the impact that it will hold upon the industry suppliers than it is towards those people that these people are in concern to function.

This motion off from the traditional methods of act uponing consumers is reflected in research and other observations. Poiesz ( 2004, p.335 ) and Bagozzi et Al ( 2002 ) find that consumer pick is driven by legion factors outside of evaluation systems. In some respects they besides consumers besides consider the formal attack displayed in studies such as the Michelin usher as being instead violative. As William Stillwell compactly put it,We ‘ve moved on from these sermons and I think more and more people go by word of oral cavity when taking where to eat. Peoples use the cyberspace and sites such as, which gather communities of like-minded people( Elliott 2008 ) .

The Nipponese illustration given in Frankler ( 2008 ) is a typical illustration of this response. A banker in his late 30 ‘s, who was interviewed with respects to a $ 200 repast that he had late experienced in a star rated eating house considered that the criterions required of the Michelin system was taking to acrying misdemeanor of Nipponese culinary art ‘s minimalist dogmas.Mentioning to an exceptionally big piece of eel that was delivered with his sushi repast ordered, he remarked,You needed a knife and fork to eat that. I can see why it would appeal to Frenchmen who do n’t utilize chopsticks.

However, despite the inauspicious remarks described antecedently, there is still an component of eating house consumers in favor of the Michelin star system and other similar quality measuring processes ( Johnson et al 2005 ) . Johnson et Al ‘s ( 2005 ) research found that in response to the ushers Michelin receive attack 50,000 letters a twelvemonth. Of these it is stated that three quarters are favorable, with the balance raising concerns and issues about the ushers and star evaluations. This degree of response has besides been reflected within the recent Internet interaction procedure introduced by the company where, as of 2005, e-mail correspondence from consumers had already reached seven thousand a twelvemonth.

4.5 Discussion

The Director of Michelin ushers was right when he suggest that, in footings of the consumer eating house experienceFood is a large portion of that. The beauty of gastronomy and the hotel concern is that you can take what you want to make for your consumer. Just do certain you get it right“ ( Foster 2007 ) . However, as the old subdivisions of this chapter have shown, when an administration is in the concern of doing opinions on the constitutions that deliver this experience to the consumer, it is every bit of import for these administrations to guarantee that all the elements of their processs, including its aims, are right as good. In footings of the general perceptual experiences, the industry and consumer reappraisals, it is clear that there is soon a really assorted reaction to the cogency and relevancy of the Michelin star system.

From an industry point of view those who support the Michelin system see that it adds quality to the concern standing, improves its fiscal public presentation and succeeds in pulling client. This is supported for other more general research, such as that carried out by the nutrients criterions bureau, which discovered that the overpowering bulk of eating houses felt that the displaying of criterions and evaluation was a good thought, with 72 % of the sentiment that clients took notice of evaluations ( Greenstreet Berman 2006, p.19 and 22 ) . The same study found that in the chief consumers were antiphonal to this state of affairs, although non to the same grade.

There is small uncertainty from this research that, peculiarly with respect to the industry participants, the Michelin system still has relevancy at many degrees. For illustration, in footings of publicity it can be seen to be good in two chief countries. The first, and possibly most of import of these is its promotional value for the concern or the chef. For illustration, Television chef Gordon Ramsey has received universe broad exposure because of the criterions of his culinary accomplishments. It is likely that the figure of Michelin stars his assorted eating house endeavors have collected have contributed to this degree of media exposure. It is likewise besides likely to be the instance that should his concern imperium start to lose these stars in Numberss, Ramsey ‘s media and promotional value could worsen. The same applies for the other good known chefs who gain exposure and external gross through books and other media activity because of their Michelin standing.

The 2nd advantageous facet to being starred by Michelin is the type of client that is attracted to these constitutions. There is small uncertainty that eating houses with Michelin stars, partly because of the cost of deriving and keeping this award, present their merchandise, in other words the eating house repast and drinks, at a higher monetary value than would be appropriate in a eating house that was non rated. Furthermore, in line with the distinction gaining a premium monetary value the consumer section for these constitutions is likely to be one that can afford to pay an increased measure and less probably to concern themselves with value for money.

However, there are restrictions to the benefits these famous person chefs ‘ experiences from their star evaluation, although it is dubious at that place would be excessively much concern in this regard. Surely, in footings of market incursion the growing degrees are being limited due to the fact many of these constitutions have a limited entreaty in footings of consumer sections. Second, except for the elect few chefs who have gained trade name popularity, the work load demand and profitableness degrees of the rated constitutions are more hard to keep, necessitating a well higher degree of investing than those constitutions that are outside of this evaluation system.

From a consumer facet, it is confirmed that the addition in public to public communicating through engineering such as the Internet, the consumer trust upon established methods of information to measure criterions of quality and service within the eating house industry is decreasing. Where these are being used it is evident that they need to be more consumers focused. To accomplish this administrations such as Michelin have to guarantee that the factors within their criterions of quality and other measuring procedures are directed more suitably towards the satisfaction of consumer demands, demands and outlooks. In many respects, and surely across a figure of consumer sections, this is non the instance at present. Indeed, it can besides said to be neglecting in some countries of its bringing of benefit to the constitutions that its star system is aimed at advancing, as the agitation within that industry section clearly identifies.

Finally, the degree of quality control within the Michelin star system itself shows marks of failing and emphasis. With mistakes being made in footings of those being granted star position, the sensed deficiency of sufficient inspectors, together with deficiency of transparence in footings of prejudice, it is likely that unless these issues are addressed assurance in the trade name will further decrease.
Chapter 4 Decision

The purpose of this research was to determine whether it is necessary to hold the Michelin star system in eating house industry or non? In other words is it still relevant. In the writer ‘s sentiment it is non possible to make a unequivocal decision on this inquiry apart from stating that the star system has limited relevancy in the current eating house and hotel market place.

4.1 Where the Michelin star system has relevancy

In the writer ‘s sentiment the countries of current relevancy for the Michelin star system can be identified as follows: –

An international criterion for mensurating haute culinary art.

With the exclusion of the restrictions mentioned in footings of transparence and state prejudice, the usher and star system, with the proper factors of quality, criterions and control in topographic point, could go a planetary criterion for measuring within the eating house and hotel industry.

A promotional assistance for chefs and their concerns

Surely the Michelin system is relevant in footings of its promotional value to chefs, peculiarly those who use it to heighten the passage of their trade name across a scope of external industry sectors, such as the media, publication and other merchandise indorsement and publicity.

As a mention for certain defined sections of the consumer population

Surely, for the corporate and particular events market section, every bit good as that consumer group which is segmented within the higher income brackets, the star system is still relevant as these sectors still rely more to a great extent upon professional sentiments than other beginnings of information, and the Michelin administration has this degree of expertness.

4.2 Where the Michelin star system is non relevant.

Conversely, there are besides countries within the market place where the Michelin star system is no longer considered relevant.

A dated system

At present the system is dated in its attack in footings of the methods by which it collects and publishes the information gathered. If it wishes to keep its impact upon the consumer market, it needs to progress its web presence and interaction installations in this regard.

Exclusivity of constitutions and culinary content

Although Michelin has extended its scope of constitutions to include Public Houses, the concentration is still upon constitutions that are at the higher terminal of the eating house sector, which excludes many good quality constitutions that do n’t run within this monetary value scope and a figure of consumer sections that can non afford to partake of the dining experience at that degree

General consumer market

Insufficient attending is being given in the content of the quality and criterions standards to the nucleus elements of consumer behavior and satisfaction determiners. Therefore, it can be seen that the Michelin star system has become industry instead than consumer focused, which devalues its relevancy to the market sector that it was originally introduced to function.

Chapter 4 Recommendations

Based upon the research conducted for this undertaking, together with the findings, treatments and decisions that have been drawn from this information, the undermentioned recommendations are considered appropriate.

The Michelin star operation

For the Michelin Corporation it is recommended that the concern needs to revisit the corporate scheme to make up one’s mind which component of the market topographic point. If this is to be the chefs and constitutions runing within the eating house industry, so it has to turn to the issues that have been raised by many of those within this sector. Alternatively, if the system is to stay consumer focused, the concerns related to transparence, prejudice and consumer demands has to be incorporated within the design measurings used for quality and criterions.

Future research

To formalize the decisions reached within this research, and to add value to the findings, it is recommended that the undermentioned extra research be undertaken. In the first case, to measure the extent to which the industry is concerned with the current public presentation of the Michelin system primary research by manner of questionnaires and interviews across an extended figure of chefs and constitutions demands to be conducted. Second, a similar primary research procedure within consumer sections would besides be good in farther finding the degree of relevance that the Michelin star system has in this country.


AA ( 2008 ) . AA Hotel and Restaurant Recognition System. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: // ( Accessed 27 August 2008 )

Arnold D ( 1992 ) . The Handbook of Brand Management. Century Business: The Economist Books. London, UK.

Bagozzi, Richard P. Gurhan-Canli, Zeynep and Priester, Joseph R ( 2002 ) . The Social Psychology of Consumer Behaviour. Open University Press. Buckingham, UK.

Balasz, K. , ( 2002 ) “ Take one enterpriser: The formula for success of France ‘s great chefs. ” European Management Journal, Vol.20, No. 3, pp. 247-259

Balazs, K. , ( 2001 ) “ Leadership lessons from France ‘s great chefs. ” Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 30, No. 2, pp. 134-148

BBC News ( 2005 ) . Michelin Guide pulled over faux pas. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: // ( Accessed 23 August 2008 ) .

Chemlinski, R. , ( 2006 ) , The Perfectionist: Life and decease in haute culinary art. Penguin Books, pp64-103 ( Chapter 3- Le Guide Michelin )

Clark, M. , et Al ( 2002 ) Researching and composing thesiss in cordial reception and touristry. Thomson Learning, UK

Dingwall, G and R. ( 1997 ) , Context & A ; Method in Qualitative Research, Sage Publications, London, UK.

Column ( 2007 ) . 12-star Ramsey is Michelin King. The Metro. London, UK

Elliott ( 2008 ) . Marco Pierre White leads onslaught on ‘outdated ‘ Michelin. The Times, London, UK

Fackler, Martin ( 2008 ) . Michelin Gives Stars, but Tokyo Turns Up Nose. New York Times, New York, US

Foster, Phin ( 2007 ) . Meet the Michelin Man. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: // ( Accessed 22 August 2008 ) .

Friedman, Amanda Mosle ( 2001 ) . Famed UK chefs ditch Michelin stars, bead monetary values, encouragement concern. Nations Restaurant News. New York, US

Gehrels, S.A. , Kristanto, S and Eringa, K ( 2006 ) . Pull offing viva-voce communicating in the Michelin starred eating houses in the Netherlands. Jurnal Manajemen Perhotelan, Vol 2. No, .2, pp.47-56

Gobe, Michael ( 2002 ) Citizen Brand: 10 Commandments for Transforming a Brand in a Consumer Democracy. Allworth Press, US.

Greenstreet Berman ( 2006 ) . Tonss on the doors: Consumer and concern positions: Foods Standards Agency. London, UK

Guide ( 2008 ) . Top Michelin-rated Restaurants. Available from: Accessed ( 12 April 2008 ) .

Gupta et Al. ( August 2007 ) “ Guest Satisfaction and Restaurant Performance. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Vol. 48, pp. 284-298

Haig, Matt ( 2004 ) Brand Failures: The Truth about the 100 Biggest Branding Mistakes of All Time. Kogan Page Ltd. London, UK.

Hart, Ch. , ( 1998 ) , Making a Literature Review: Let go ofing the Social Science Research Imagination, Sage Publications Inc, London, UK

Hart, Ch. , ( 2006 ) , Making a Literature Search: A Comprehensive Guide for the Social Sciences, Sage Publications Inc, London

Hickman, Martin ( 2008 ) . The Large Question: How does the Michelin guide award its stars – and do they still count? The Independent. Available from: ( Accessed 17 April 2008 ) .

Johnson, C. , Surlemont, B. , Nicod, P. , Revaz, F. ( 2005 ) “ Behind the star: a concise typology of Michelin eating houses in Europe. ” Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Vol. 46, No. 2, pp. 170-187

Latest News ( 2008 ) . No top awards for eating houses in this old ages Michelin ‘s usher. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: // ( Accessed 12 April 2008 ) .

Maslow, Abraham, H. ( 1998 ) . Maslow on Management. John Wiley & A ; Sons, New York, U.S.

McGivern, Y. ( 2006 ) . The Practice of Market and Social Research: An Introduction, 2nd Edition, Financial Times Prentice Hall. Harlow, UK

Muller C.C. ( 1999 ) “ The concern of eating houses: 2001 and beyond ” International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.18 pp. 401-13

Namkung Young & A ; SooCheong Jang ( 2007 ) “ Does nutrient Quality Really Matter in Restaurants? Impact on Customer Satisfaction and Behavioural Intentions. ” Journal of Hospitality & A ; Tourism Research, Vol. 31, No. 3, pp.287-409

Noone et Al. ( August 2007 ) “ The Effect of Meal Pace on Customer Satisfaction. ” Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Vol. 48, pp.231-244

Petkanas, Christopher ( 2006 ) . Starred For Life: Chefs returning their hard-won stars, a tell-all book, a controversial New York City guide –Monday Dieu!– These are interesting clip for Michelin. Travel and Leisure Magazine New York, US

Poiesz, B.C ( 2004 ) . The Free Market Illusion of Psychological Limitations of Consumer Choice. Tijdschrift voor Economie en Management Vol. XLIX, 2, pp.308-338

Porter, Michael E ( 2004 ) . Competitive Scheme: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. The Free Press. New erectile dysfunction. The Free Press. New York, US.

Punch, K. ( 1998 ) . Introduction to societal research. SAGE Publications. London, UK.

Snyder, W. , Cotter, M. , ( 1998 ) “ The Michelin Guide and Restaurant Pricing Strategies. ” Journal of Restaurant & A ; Foodservice Marketing, Vol.3 ( 1 ) , pp. 51-67

Steward, D. W. & A ; Kamins, M. A. ( 1993 ) , Secondary Research: Information Beginnings and Methods, 2nd Edition, Sage Publications, London, UK

Surlemont, B. , Chantrain, D. , Nlemvo, F. , Johnson, C. ( 2005 ) “ Revenue theoretical accounts in haute culinary art: an explorative analysis. ” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.17, No.4, pp. 286-301

Surlemont, B. , Johnson, C. ( 2005 ) “ The function of ushers in artistic industries: The particular instance of ‘star system ‘ in the haute-cuisine sector. ” Pull offing Service Quality, Vol. 15, Issue 6, pp. 577-590

Szmigin, I. , ( 2003 ) Understanding the Consumer. SAGE Publication, London

Video Links ( 2008 ) . Gary Rhodes and Anthony Demetre on winning another Michelin star. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: // ( Accessed 14 April 2008 ) .

Yuksel, Atila and Yuksel, Fisun ( 2003 ) “ Measurement of tourer satisfaction with eating house services: A segment-based attack. ” Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 9, pp. 52-68

Zaltman, Jerry ( 2003 ) How Customers Think. Essential Insights into the head of the market. Harvard Business School Press. Massachusetts, US.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.