Posted on

Discussion of the role of Consultants in the Decision-Making process

Consulting is the concern of supplying consultative services to the leaders of an organisation. Advisers are considered as job convergent thinker who have expertness and outside position of covering with a job. The aim of this essay is to discourse the function of the adviser in client ‘s determination devising procedure. The critical analysis will concentrate on every facet of the adviser ‘s duty as facilitator in the determination doing procedure in context with Coral Telecom Limited ( CTL ) . It aims to show the practical cognition of theories and theoretical accounts learnt all over the faculty. Furthermore, a deep analytical treatment will be embedded throughout.

Report starts with the definition of consulting and the function of adviser in modern-day concern followed by the adviser and client relationship. Thereafter, the function of a adviser as facilitator in client ‘s decision-making is explained. Before discoursing the factors that influence decision-making in organisation, the procedure of decision-making and the decision-making unit is elaborated. After this the appetency for decision-making will take to the account of alteration procedure. Finally the importance of communicating to present alteration and the responses of persons will be considered.

2. What is Consulting?

Consulting is the concern of supplying adept advice to clients in return of fee to assist them work out their job within a peculiar country of concern ( Salmon 1995 ) . Advisers are the persons holding expertness every bit good as the ability to use that expertness to practical job work outing. Koch confer withing explains that the function of a adviser is to help direction in the diagnosing of the jobs, explicate factual information, recommend optimal solutions and aid in execution activities ( 2009 ) . Consultant involves experienced professionals who analyses client ‘s state of affairs utilizing the information provided and information obtained. Advisers besides relates the state of affairs, potencies and concern attitude to practical and action based solutions to get at the most economical and feasible recommendations.

Wickham articulates advisers as information suppliers who give information to direction. This “ information is used to analyse possible classs of action and so to warrant the determination finally ” ( Wickham 2007 ) . CTL hired a adviser to cover with hard currency crunch and increase capital.

3. Consultant- Client Relationship

Harmonizing to Sobel, client relationship is a non-mechanical procedure of pull offing clients. As per his statement “ it is a system of schemes and methods, led by a senior relationship director, for prosecuting with client executives, constructing trust, adding value, and conveying to bear the best people, thoughts, and resources your house can offer in order to assist the client accomplish its ends ” ( Sobel 2007 ) .

CTL wanted a relationship with a sure adviser and a adviser earns trust by turn outing concern for, penetration in and cognition of the client ‘s concern. Therefore client outlooks seem to be the nucleus concern for the adviser.

From CTL ‘s outlooks perspective, adviser can see the assignment in a three stage theoretical account:

Discover: stage in which CTL outlooks are unearthed Define: stage in which outlooks are given form, signifier and boundaries Deliver: stage wherein activities are performed to run into the outlooks ( Khosla 2004 )

In order to construct healthy relationship with CTL and to ease CTL leaders in doing right determination, adviser must understand the factors act uponing determination devising in an organisation.

4. Adviser as Facilitator

Facilitator is an person who helps to pull off a procedure of information exchange. Harmonizing to Bob Kelsch of Xerox Corporation, facilitator means “ Steering without directing ; conveying about alteration without break ; strike harding down walls which have been built between people whilst continuing constructions of value… and, above all, appreciate people as people. All of this must be done without go forthing any fingerprints ” . Facilitation attack is normally recommended when the organisation is concerned about the manner determination is madeA and non simply what determination is made.

Therefore harmonizing to Institute ofA Cultural Affairs, Canada, a adviser needs to posses following accomplishments as a facilitator:

Knowledge of job resolution and procedure redesign techniques and practical experience of implementing them

Excellent communicating accomplishments to pass on at different degrees in the organisation

Training accomplishments to present messages to employees

Good hearing and oppugning accomplishments to cognize the root cause of the issue

Acting as a counsellor than a sergeant and wise man than a scientist and

Ability to maintain focal point on the ‘big image ‘ while presenting the alteration

As facilitator, a adviser must explicate the procedure stairss to CTL leaders and must lodge to the procedure with some room for flexibleness. To make so adviser demand to larn the decision-making procedure in CTL.

5. Decision Making Procedure

Decision devising is a cognitive procedure of choosing a class of action amongst several options. Henry Mintzberg ( 1979 ) said that organisational decision-making is doing a committedness to action. Decision devising is an of import accomplishment that directors must possess and every director is expected to do the right determination. Since corporate determination doing procedure is of extreme importance for effectual direction, the procedure of determination devising is informed by expert cognition and experience ( Heller and Bono 2004 ) . Baker et Al ( 2001 ) says “ efficient decision-making involves a series of stairss that require the input of information at different phases of the procedure, every bit good as a procedure for feedback ” .

To take the right determination, a direction hires a adviser who provides the factual information, information and beliefs about the state of affairs. Consultant ‘s cognition and experience in covering with such state of affairs helps directors to take the right determination. The information, information, facts and beliefs that constitute determination, must hence be reliable and must be informed good by the advisers. Three wide theories of decision-making procedure are:

Normative – what rational decision-maker does

Descriptive- what really people does

Prescriptive – what directors should make

( Matthias 2011 ) .



Harmonizing to Richard Bowett, the theoretical account shown in fig.1 is normative theoretical account of determination devising because it illustrates the procedure of taking a good determination. Interaction between persons at each degree of this theoretical account is necessary to understand effectual determination devising.

In order to be effectual in back uping the CTL to accomplish its aims, adviser must understand the manner in which determinations are really made, justified and implemented in CTL ( Wickham and Wickham 2007 ) . Therefore adviser must follow the below degrees of penetration:

Appreciation of the types of determination to be made

Acknowledging the people involved in determination devising

Understanding the attack in which determination is defined

Ability to specify the ways of determination devising that an organisation may follow.

6. Decision Making Unit

Decision doing unit ( DMU ) is the group of directors within an organisation, who interact as a whole to carry through determination doing procedure. Poole and Akhter in there article on decision-making procedures states that “ determinations are undertaken by people within organisations, and apprehension of organisational decision-making procedures is closely linked to the function attributed to participants in the determination procedure ” . Thus, a adviser must acknowledge the undermentioned key participants in DMU, so that he/she can ease client ‘s determination.

Decision Maker: individual who really makes determination and is responsible for the results of the determination.

Authorizer: authorizes, modifies or countenances the determination is taken by determination shaper.

Information Supplier: provides information and information which is analyzed by determination shaper in order to take possible class of action and to warrant the determination.

Resource Supplier: authorizes the usage of resources that are required before execution of the determination.

Influencer: puts the determination into consequence e.g. operations, R & A ; D and gross revenues squad

Consultant must acknowledge all the DMU members in CTL and should lend to sustainable development by extinguishing obstructors to optimized determination devising.

7. Factors Influencing Decision Making in Organizations

To ease CTL leaders in decision-making without altering the determination, a adviser is expected to understand and follow the decision-making manner in the client organisation. The three major factors that influence determination devising are:

Organizational Orientation

Organizational Culture and

Strategy Process

Organizational Orientation:

These are the precedences that an organisation is believed to hold focus on and the issues refering to them. As explained by Wickham and Wickham, there can be three different types of orientations that an organisation may hold: production, gross revenues and selling ( 2007 ) .

Production Orientation: organisations holding production orientation dressed ores on developing the merchandises or services it provides instead than their demand ( Wickham 2007 ) .

Gross saless Orientation: Such organisations give precedence to determinations focused on gross revenues scheme and short term promotional tactics. CTL aims to increase its capital by concentrating on gross revenues.

Marketing Orientation: Such concerns are concerned with the determinations focused on developing strategic selling attack.

Organizational Culture:

Culture of an organisation has a major impact on its determination devising procedure. Therefore adviser needs to understand CTL ‘s civilization to help client efficaciously in doing determination and implementing it. There can be four wide classs of civilization in an organisation as sufficed by Wickham:

Power civilization: Often found in little houses, this civilization is dominated by a individual individual who is the beginning of all authorization in the organisation and besides dominates the DMU. CTL follows this civilization and the pull offing manager Acts of the Apostless as the authorization.

Role civilization: such civilizations define single functions through occupation descriptions and specifications. There are chiseled sections and their maps.

Task civilization: Business in such civilizations is segregated into squads instead than sections and the determination devising is centered on the undertaking squad.

Person civilization: Decision devising in these civilizations is informal since such organisations give precedence to internal environment instead than external universe.

Strategy Procedure:

A adviser must cognize the scheme procedure of an organisation which consists of the content of the scheme and the procedure of the scheme. Content of the scheme signifies the existent concern, an organisation does and the procedure tells the manner in which organisation decides what to make.

8. Change: Appetite for Decision Making

Decision doing procedure starts when the direction needs alteration of some sort in the organisation. “ Consulting chances arise due to the clients ‘ desire to set about alteration within its organisation and its realisation that it requires external aid to make this ” ( Khosla 2004 ) . Desire for alteration could originate from several intrinsic and extrinsic factors such as alteration in market, competition and engineering or alteration in stakeholder outlooks, vision and function of the company. Losing market portion and recognition crunch induced a desire for alteration in CTL leaders.

Consultant ‘s function is to help CTL leaders in finding the chief jobs, to convey effectual alterations to get by with those jobs and to pull off any opposition to alterations among CTL employees ( Waters 2010 ) . After detecting CTL ‘s orientation, civilization and interacting with DMU members, adviser identified that CTL lacks in the engineering it uses for its merchandise development. CTL ‘s rivals adopted latest engineering and increased their market portion and gross revenues while CTL followed the traditional engineering and lost the market portion, ensuing in reduced gross revenues.

9. Change Procedure

Dr. John Kotter says that 70 % of all major alteration attempts in organisations fail because organisations do non follow the appropriate attack to see the alteration. Kotter outlines the undermentioned eight phase procedure of alteration that a adviser must understand while helping alteration directors in organisations.

Step-1: Making a sense of urgency

When some people notice the exposure in the organisation, they need to set up a sense of urgency among others for prompt action. Consultant assisted the MD of CTL in demoing the large image and actuating the employees to make a sense of urgency.

Step-2: Making a alliance

The alteration leader should garner all those people who support alteration and have adequate motive to do it go on. Consultant interacted with the alteration squad to happen its weak countries and guarantee that it consist of people from different sections and degrees of CTL.

Step-3: Developing vision and scheme

Change leader must demo the vision and impact of the alteration on organisation and suggest schemes to accomplish the coveted alteration. Consultant figured out CTL ‘s vision for alteration in order to actuate and ease people efficaciously.

Stage-4: Communicating the alteration vision

Management must pass on the alteration vision among relevant employees to heighten their motive to take part. CTL asked the adviser to pass on its vision to employees

Stage-5: Empowering employees and taking barriers

Employees should be provided all the resources needed to move in conformity with the vision and should be encouraged to take hazards. Consultant assisted CTL leaders in placing the barriers and ways to extinguish them.

Stage-6: Generating short-run wins

Communicating the advancement to employees and honoring at the same clip can develop a feeling of success and jubilation. A adviser may help alteration leaders in making these short-run ends and in honoring the employees.

Stage-7: Consolidating betterments and maintaining the impulse for alteration traveling

Kotter warns that triumph should non be declared until alterations sink profoundly into organisation ‘s civilization. A premature declaration of triumph may take to acrimonious effects giving infinite to resistances to emerge.

Stage-8: Anchoring new attacks to civilization

Finally, a alteration should be absorbed in the organisation ‘s civilization in a manner that the value behind the vision must be seen in daily working. It is besides required that leader ‘s continue to back up alteration and new leaders adopt it.

10. Communicating Change

Harmonizing to John Stark the manner of pass oning the alteration is really of import to get the better of the fright and concerns aroused by alteration ( 2000 ) . Employees become oddities to cognize the impact of alteration on their occupation, place, function and hereafter of the organisation. Prosecuting employees is critical for a successful alteration and effectual communicating with employees is cardinal to making that. Kotter notes that most of the alteration plans fail due to miss of communicating of alteration to the staff that implements it. Kelly M. Gordon states that “ alteration will non be efficaciously implemented unless it is communicated to an organisation ‘s staff in such a manner that opposition is overcome, frights are assuaged, confusion is minimized, and buy-in by all affected persons is secured ” ( 2006 ) . The purpose of communicating is to present information that changes behavior in front-line employees.

For alteration to be successful in CTL, people must cognize and understand the demand to alter ( Wells 2007 ) . Merely supplying information is non communicating, therefore advisers need to do certain that employees have a voice in determination and their position is heard, considered and responded before determination is made. In order to pass on alteration efficaciously, adviser took attention of the likely responses to alter and presented the benefits that change ( migrating the merchandise development to latest engineering ) could lend to CTL and its employees.

11. Responses to Change

Peter Stark suggests that employees ‘ response to alter can be due to several factors runing from fright and terror to enthusiastic support ( 2010 ) . Change in the economic and the concern environment forces some organisations to alter the manner of making business.A Advisers must understand the ground behind employee ‘s response to alter and help directors and leaders in planing a alteration scheme consequently.

Quoting Michael W. Durant words “ Organizational alteration has an component of loss inherent in the procedure, and it is a loss that is frequently profoundly felt by employees ” ( 1999 ) . In order to ease clients in their determination devising procedure and alteration, a adviser needs to understand the emotional quotient of the employees. This can be understood utilizing Kubler-Ross passage rhythm which has five phases:

Denial: employees might react by disregarding the issue

Anger: opposition to alter

Bargaining: to set off alteration or happen an alternate manner out to the state of affairs

Depression: when bargaining fails, employees feel down and low in energy

Credence: when nil works, employees accept the alteration


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.